The Crumbly Old Castle: Irish Apple Cake Recipe​

I like to bake things I read about in my research for books that aren’t set in my area. One of the things I found and liked best for Ireland while writing The Crumbly Old Castle was a traditional Irish Apple Cake.

I changed some things to make the recipe more “American friendly,” and my family loved this so much that I’ve found myself making it once or twice a week for months now. You’ve been warned!
 

Special equipment:

A springform pan, spatula(s), and if you have one, a double boiler makes this much simpler. You can use a pot on the bottom with water and a metal bowl above it as well.
 

Ingredients:

Cake:

  • 1/2 cup unsalted butter at room temperature
  • 1/2 cup sugar
  • 2 large eggs
  • 3 Tbsp whole milk or cream
  • 1.25 cups all purpose flour
  • 1 tsp baking powder
  • 1 tsp cinnamon
  • 1/8 tsp salt
  • confectioner’s sugar for dusting on top
  • 3 honey crisp or other crisp apples, peeled and thinly sliced. (usually just over a pound once sliced, if you’re worried; slice them very, very thin or they will be crunchy when you’re done baking).

Streusel Topping

  • 3/4 cup flour (all purpose)
  • 1/3 cup oats (I prefer rolled)
  • 7 Tbsp unsalted cold butter, cut in small pieces
  • 1/2 cup sugar

Custard

(I had to make this THREE TIMES before I got it just right, and I found that using a double boiler made it WAY easier to get right. I make custard somewhat frequently, but this is a difficult custard sauce recipe, in my opinion. It’s delicious, though, so I thought it was worth it. My family doesn’t like the cake nearly as well without the sauce.)
 
  • 6 large egg yolks
  • 6 Tbsp sugar
  • 1.5 cups whole milk (or! I used 1 cup of 2 percent/1 percent and added 1/2 cream!)
  • 1.5 tsp vanilla

Instructions:

1. Preheat the oven to 350.
 
2. Custard. Make the custard sauce first so you have time to cool it. Bring the milk to a simmer over medium heat. While you’re doing that, whisk the egg yolks and sugar until they’re well mixed. With a 1/4 cup measure, scoop some of the hot milk and pour it into the egg mixture, whisking it the whole time so it will not cook the eggs. This is called proofing them. Do this TWO more times with 1/4 cup or so of the milk each time. Then combine the egg and sugar mixture with the rest of the milk over the pot, stirring constantly. Keep it over medium heat and stir it until you notice it’s thickening. Here’s where I screwed up a few times. It will NEVER get super thick. If you’re waiting for that, you’ll cook the egg! So once it starts to coat the spoon or spatula or whisk you’re using, turn it off. I also recommend that you have a tupperware container with a strainer over the top, so when you are done, pour the custard sauce through that and into the container. Add the vanilla and whisk it up, then pop the top on and put it in the fridge to cool while you make the cake. Without a secure top, your custard will form a crust on top while cooling.
 
3. Streusel topping. This one’s easy. Literally just blend it all up with a fork. You’re going to think it will NEVER come together, but it will. it’s not going to be blobs, though. It’ll be kind of clingy powder and small clumps with some oatmeal, and that’s just what you want, I swear! Leave that bowl on the counter while you do the other two parts.
 
4. Cake base. I literally just dump everything into a bowl and use beaters to mix it all up. I don’t do anything fussy or first, and it’s just fine. You will need to then grease the springform pan (I just used Pam) and spread this in the bottom of it. It’s a little tricky, because this is sticky. Smooth it out as much as you can.
 
5. Apples. Peel and slice your apples here, and I arrange them inside down in little runs. I think it’s kind of fun. I suppose you could just dump them in. I think the tiny, thin slices are key to this cooking just right. It’s not quite as good when you overcook it, so…
 
6. Assembly. Dump the streusel on top of the cake and spread it around. THE ORIGINAL recipe says to bake for 50-60 minutes at 350. This resulted in an overcooked cake on our end. I don’t like overcooked things. I also have a “true convection” oven, meaning mine drops the temp by 25 degrees because it moves the air around with fans AND has heating elements on ALL SIDES of the oven. If you simply have an oven with a fan on the back, I’m not sure how it will go. As most bakers know, the baking is the temperamental part. You may have to play with it. All my recipes have little notes on the baking times and temps. (I toy with them until I find a fit for MY oven.) But what worked perfectly for ME was 44 minutes at 325 convection. You can certainly try pulling a toothpick out of the center, but I think with the apples and streusel, it’s harder to tell whether it’s fully cooked that way.
 
7. Final touches. Once it comes out, if your house is like my house, you will be swarmed with people. Husband, sons, daughters. All of them want a slice. Make them wait ten minutes while it finishes baking in that springform pan. During the end of that time, use a sieve to sprinkle powdered sugar on the top. Then you can pop the springform off the edges and let them cut a slice. They can spoon on as much or as little custard as they want.
 
Enjoy!